Showing posts with label feminsim. Show all posts
Showing posts with label feminsim. Show all posts

Tuesday, 23 August 2011

The Fantine Problem


I’ve been out of the country for the last few weeks. I’d prefer not to go a whole month without posting, or I’ll be constantly annoyed by the missing month in the archives. Now if you’ll excuse me, I have to go and wash my hands for exactly six minutes and forty seconds.

Right then. All done. Now – having said that I’m a feminist, how fast do you think I could lose the sympathy of every single feminist in the world? Here it is in two words – ‘Legalise prostitution’*. Now, before you hunt me down with torches and pitchforks, let’s be clear here. The idea of prostitution disgusts me, I’d have trouble actually bringing myself to associate with anyone who’d actually avail themselves of the services of a prostitute, even if it were legalised. Indeed, if they were legal, I’d be prepared to spend considerable effort putting them all out of business. But this isn’t about the morality of prostitution. It’s about the morality of using the law to stop it, which is subtly different. Besides, if we were going to outlaw things just because they disgusted me, we’d have to outlaw sex**.

So what’s wrong with outlawing prostitution? After all, If we’re all agreed that it’s morally repugnant***, why not just stop people doing it? A couple of reasons. Firstly, there’s the classic drug argument that it’s quite a bit easier to regulate things when they’re legal. Legal regulation of criminal activity tends to be somewhat futile. For the record, there are a few reasons I take a different attitude to this argument here than I do when it’s used in the case of drugs, but I’m not going into that here. The point is that prostitution is currently a popular reason for human trafficking. You could probably reduce that quite a lot if legal prostitution existed.

Then there’s the question of exactly why women**** would go into prostitution. You won’t get any argument from me that almost anyone becomes a prostitute for any reason other than because they’ve not really got much other choice (or because they’ve been tricked into it). Which gets into the question of what exactly ‘freely given consent’ means. There are rather a lot of opinions on that, from ‘anyone who says yes gives irrevocable consent, in some cases, even if you lied to persuade them to do so’ to ‘It’s impossible for women to give consent because of the influence of the patriarchy.’††. There’s a fairly good argument to be made that if someone has a choice between death by starvation and prostitution, they’re being raped when they decide on the latter (even if it’s a little difficult to determine who exactly the rapist is). The thing is, I’ve always been rather an advocate of the lesser of two evils. If someone’s going to starve to death if they don’t go into prostitution, then if you take away the option of prostitution, they’re going to starve to death. Personally, I’d take the prostitution, and even if you’d prefer the alternative, you can still take it†††. And if they’re not going to starve to death, then they have the option. The thing is that I’d question anyone ever considering, it’s still an extra bit of freedom that harms noone except the person doing it. I’d say that anything that increases freedom without hurting anything is a good thing. Maybe noone would avail themselves of this freedom – I rather hope they wouldn’t. But on the other hand, there are seven billion people in the world at the time of writing. One or two might surprise you. But the point isn’t whether anyone actually does it. The point is that you shouldn’t stop them if they want to, that freedom shouldn’t be restricted without good reason.

Which leaves me in the rather odd position of opposing prostitution, but defending people’s right to do it. I disagree with what you do, but I will defend to the death your right to do it.

Now you can hunt me down with torches and pichforks.

*I would also have accepted ‘Women suck’, but it’d be a little tricky to actually justify that one.
**And, for that matter, coleslaw.
***You don’t count Hubert.
****And as a side note, I find it fascinating that prostitution is just about the only job you can still basically think of as ‘women’s work’ without objections. I’ve yet to decide whether this is because of the fact that the people who normally object to that kind of thing are too busy objecting to prostitution to object to the stereotypes associated with it, or whether it’s just the whole ‘men are sex addicts’ stereotype†.
†Which also fascinates me, but I won’t go into that now, except to mention that the ancient Greeks thought the exact opposite.
††And in the interests of fairness, I must point out that both these position are pretty extreme. Most people are going to be rather a lot further towards the middle, no matter what my RS textbook says about the second one being ‘the feminist position’.
†††And yes, I’m aware that this is pretty much like saying that I’d rather have my fingernails ripped out with rusty pliers than have needles driven through my eyes††††.
††††Both of which will probably happen to me if I keep publishing things like this.

Sunday, 10 July 2011

Basic feminism (Feminism 101 was taken).

If you’re wondering about the gap, it’s because I couldn’t think of anything to say. I want to talk about Libya, but two political posts in a row seems a bit much. So today I’m going to talk about something completely apolitical. Feminism! After all, what kind of hopelessly ignorant person would oppose such a self-evidently worthy cause as feminism? Apart from, for example, most of the human males* on the planet**. This is going to be less political than philosophical, though, since, I’m going to be describing what we believe.

First, as both of the people who actually read my introduction probably noticed, yes, I’m a feminist. Not all feminists are actually female. Just most of us. Which is because the point of feminism is to eliminate any and all sexual gender discrimination (which should make them a natural ally of LGBTIQAA***, but I’ve never really encountered that much contact between them, since both sides tend to keep to their own issues for the most part). To exclude males would, in fact, be gender discrimination.

Which brings me to the idea of feminists as 'man-haters'****. Or even the idea that a large number of feminists are 'man-haters'. Let’s be clear here. That’s not feminism, it’s misandry. If you look closely, you can see a slight difference in spelling between those two words. A misandrist might call themselves a feminist, but that doesn’t actually make them one, especially since they’re in direct opposition to what feminism actually stand for. It’s the same as how calling yourself communist doesn’t actually make you one, and why people don’t bow before me, despite my referring to myself as ‘God-king of all humanity’. Also, the number of ‘feminist’ misandrists is a lot lower than people seem to think. There’s a story everyone seems to know about how a man opens a door for a woman, and she starts raging at him for sexism. The strange thing is that no one seems to have actually had it happen to them. I’m pretty sure at this point that it’s an urban legend, but even if it’s true, it proves nothing except the existence of idiots in the feminist movement. All groups have idiots*****.

Another thing people always bring up is ‘radical feminsim’. Clearly man hating feminists exist as a significant proportion of the movement, they say, since there’s a whole section on Wikipedia on ‘Radical Feminism’. You keep using those words. I do not think they mean what you think they mean. Although I have several philosophical differences with the ideas of radical feminism, and even more with some specific radical feminists, radical feminism does not mean hatred of men, and next time you might want to try actually reading up on the theory, rather than just reading a bit on radical Islam, and assuming that all radical views are basically the same kind of thing

Which actually leads to the idea people seem to have that all feminism is one big united group, or that there are feminist views on things. Now, to some extent, that’s true. For example: rape is bad. But the thing about feminism is that it’s about equality between the sexes. How we’re going to achieve that equality, and even what it’ll look like when we get there isn’t exactly a point of unity.

Another thing to address, of course, is why it’s called feminism, rather than, say, ‘egalitarianism’. Far too many people say that they don’t identify as feminist because of the name being orientated towards females. As though it mattered what a philosophy was called. But let’s look at this logically: Rape victims are mostly female (although still not all); ditto domestic abuse victims; the only country in Europe to elect two female heads of state in a row is Ireland; females get paid less; promiscuous women are derided; massive amounts of film, advertising and drawing is focused on portraying the women as sex objects (google ‘male gaze’). In return, females get to wear nice clothes (so that they’re nicer for heterosexual men to look at), get to learn dancing (so that they can show off their bodies to heterosexual men), and get more control over their children (partly because they had to have a baby in their body for nine months and suffer the pain of childbirth, but mostly because females are naturally the primary caregivers, far better at bringing up children than males). When the feminist movement started, things were even more skewed. So yeah, even though I’m slanting that a little, I think calling it feminism and placing the focus on women’s rights is probably understandable.

I can’t currently think of any more things you need to know about feminism, although it’s always possible that I’ve wiped some of the stupider objections from my mind. This is rather general because there are some more specific things I want to talk about, and I wanted to do some groundwork first, just to make my position clear.

* Quick aside: male/female refers to sex, which is biological, whilst man/woman refers to gender, which is cultural. Feminist philosophy tends to be a bit more focused on gender discrimination. That’s a bit of an oversimplification, but it’ll do for now.
** Based on talking to about twenty of them about it. Truly, mine is a well researched and totally non-sexist statement.
*** I’ve probably missed out a few letters there.
**** Actually, it brings me to the idea of butterflies. But unfortunately, butterflies have nothing to do with this post, so let’s go with the vaguely logical connection.
***** Except people who read this blog, who are all handsome, charming and intelligent†.
†Except you Hubert††.
††Apologies to anyone actually called Hubert.